Debt Settlement vs. Bankruptcy: Which Is Right For You?

Debt Settlement vs. Bankruptcy: Which Is Right For You?

03:56 AM August 09, 2019

Is there a faster way out of debt? Yes, there is. Bankruptcy is the swiftest way out of debt, but it has long-term consequences on your credit score. Bankruptcy can either clear your personal debt loan (Chapter 7 bankruptcy) or open doors for suitable debt repayment and debt management plan (Chapter 13 bankruptcy).

The most direct methods for getting out of debt — debt settlement and bankruptcy — are both efficient, but each has different implications on your future financial status.

It’s high time you started considering these two options if you have bogus unpaid debts.

Let’s say you file for bankruptcy, the bankruptcy notification would remain on your credit reports for seven to ten years, depending on the type of bankruptcy filed.

This notification would stop other creditors from lending you money in the future.

Unlike bankruptcy, debt settlement doesn’t call for a court case and oftentimes, can be settled without credit counseling or lawyer negotiation.

The aim of applying for debt settlement programs is to cut a fair deal, which lowers your interests and loan balance.

Why Would Lenders Want to Negotiate Your Debts for Less Than You Owe?

Creditors don’t want you to file for bankruptcy because there’s a possibility of total debt elimination in court.

To avoid going to court, they prefer getting less than you owe via debt settlement.

Peradventure you don’t have the ability to pay at all, bankruptcy could be a better way out.
There are two types of personal bankruptcies, namely: Chapter 13 and Chapter 7.

Chapter 13 involves a repayment plan, which could take three to five years while Chapter 7 eliminates all personal debts with future implications.

Under Chapter 13, you would be allowed to keep your house, but you’d be mandated to pay for a mortgage after you leave the bankruptcy court.

Under Chapter 7, there’s no such guarantee — the court could allow bankruptcy trustees to trade your house to pay back your lenders.

In addition to losing your home, chapter 7 sets a limit on your monthly income, thereby making you earn less than the state’s median wage for your family size.

Bankruptcy saves you from debt collection. However, freedom comes at a painful price.

You can achieve the same financial freedom without headaches by using debt settlement though it would take more time.

If negotiations are properly done, debt settlement is the best way out of unsecured debt.

Comprehending the advantages and disadvantages of debt settlement vs bankruptcy and making the wisest decision can have a huge impact on your future finances.

Choosing Debt Settlement or Bankruptcy

Fred hasn’t made his minimum payments for three months — he’s been struggling with his finances for over a year. Despite his low income, his bills, like utilities and medical bills, got bigger. Then, Fred came to a bitter conclusion that he’d have to file for bankruptcy if things got worse.

After calculating the amount needed to keep paying his mortgage, he realized that he could sustain his mortgage if he dropped credit card bills.

Fred went for Credit Counseling and was took the advice to opt-in for the debt settlement process. He halted his monthly payments and notified his credit card agency that he couldn’t meet up with the payment schedule.

With the Help of a Debt Settlement Company

With the help of a debt settlement company, he was able to negotiate with his lenders and consolidated all his debts into a single payment.

Also, Fred’s debt and interest rate were reduced considerably without risking being reported to the credit rating authorities.

Fred paid his monthly payments in full to the debt settlement company, as agreed and cleared all his loan debts in a year, thereby preventing his creditworthiness from being damaged.

Unlike Fred, Janet’s case was different — both of them were in debt, but Janet had more challenges.

Her husband was laid off and couldn’t find another job. She could barely take care of the mortgage, let alone make a monthly payment from her account. When she thought things couldn’t get any worse, her husband had a heart attack and the medical fees were unbearable.

After studying all available options, Janet and her husband filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy.

Their homes were defended from foreclosure, as long as she made payments and all her debts were of elimination, giving her tons of debt relief options.

In Janet’s case, debt settlement isn’t advisable, as she and her husband didn’t earn enough income to settle. Bankruptcy was inevitable.

Impact of Bankruptcy and Debt Settlement on Credit
Why debt settlement may be a good option

Have it at the back of your mind that bankruptcy and debt settlement could have negative effects on your credit score and lessen your credit or FICO score for years.

Regardless of which chapter you file under, bankruptcy would certainly reduce your creditworthiness. The higher the score you started with, the lower it drops.

A Chapter 7 bankruptcy is boldly written on your credit report for a decade from the day of filing while a Chapter 13 bankruptcy remains on your credit report for seven years.

After seven years, the accounts linked with a bankruptcy or debt settlement are detached from your report after they’ve become delinquent.

Bankruptcy Laws and Regulations

There are bankruptcy laws and regulations that determine what happens to your funds after the final judgment is declared. Like we noted earlier, chapter 13 mandates partial repayment while Chapter 7 gets rid of your debt. The bankruptcy judge determines how much you have to repay according to the state laws, which may involve debt collectors.

Debt settlement allows you to make lesser payments to free your account from outstanding debts and then soon increase your savings account. Assuming you’re not able to make payments immediately (most debtors can’t ), you’d be required to take a break till you’ve saved enough to cover the debt.

Taking a break could further hurt your credit score and incur late fees. However, if they don’t report the settlement to the appropriate authorities, it might take less time to rebuild your creditworthiness.

Check if you qualify in two simple steps

  • Step 1 – Select your debt amount below to see if you’re eligible
  • Step 2 –Answer a few quick questions & join hundreds of thousands of Americans on the path to becoming debt-free

Pros and Cons of Debt Settlement

Like bankruptcy, debt settlement has its own pitfalls. The first problem is negotiating a fair deal that can sometimes involve a debt attorney, which requires the lender or multiple credit agencies to get less than you own them.

There’s no rule mandating lenders to enter a settlement agreement, but more often than not they are willing to come to terms with you if they believe you’re not capable of paying back and bankruptcy is inevitable.
You can either hire a debt settlement firm to negotiate on your behalf or negotiate yourself.

Hiring a debt settlement firm saves time and protects you from the hassle of negotiating yourself and getting yourself out of possible lawsuits.

Pros of Settling a Debt

  • Make lower payments to become debt-free
  • Prevent the long-term damage that comes with a bankruptcy filing
  • Settle with lenders and prevent the waste of time, effort and money involved in bankruptcy

Cons to Debt Settlement:

  • Lenders might be reluctant to settle with you
  • When lenders realize that you can’t pay, they may take legal actions to garnish your income.
  • Halting payments to further convince your lenders that you can’t afford to pay might damage your credit score.
  • They require you to pay taxes on the forgiven amount since the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) sees it as income.

Pros and Cons of Bankruptcy

Looking for avenues to eliminate your debts legally? Chapter 7 and chapter 13 are the two legal options available. Though chapter 7 is tempting, you might be required to forfeit all you own, including your cars and houses to pay off your debts.

Unlike chapter 7, chapter 13 protects your house from foreclosure. However, you’re mandating to pay your lender partially for a three to five year period.

Chapter 13 bankruptcy is also called the wage earners bankruptcy, as it requires partial repayment.

Here’s the plot twist — student loan debt, income taxes, and child support debts cannot be eliminated with bankruptcy. Both chapters would leave a negative impact on your creditworthiness. The best option is to consider some sort of payment plan.

Pros to Bankruptcy Chapter 7

  • Eliminate most debts and provides a fresh beginning.
  • Doesn’t mandate the filer to make tax payments on unpaid debts
  • Stop lenders from demanding debt collections

Cons to Bankruptcy Chapter 7

  • Hurt creditworthiness for a decade.
  • Some states allow foreclosures of home and other assets. Check which state allows it.
  • The mandate you to wait for eight years before filing under another chapter 7 bankruptcy.

Pros of Bankruptcy Chapter 13

  • Defend your home and cars against foreclosure
  • You’re discharged after completing the required payments
  • You don’t have to pay taxes on forgiven debts
  • The waiting duration is lesser — two years

Cons of Bankruptcy Chapter 13

  • The mandate you to pay a particular amount for three to five years
  • Lower your credit score for seven years, thereby making it difficult to obtain a personal loan


Settling credit card debt is sometimes tasking. If you don’t know how to negotiate debt with credit card companies, hire a debt settlement agency, bankruptcy attorney, consult some financial counselors, or a credit counselor.

For those who want to know the good option between debt consolidation and bankruptcy, anticipate our next post titled: debt consolidation vs bankruptcy.

Subscribe to our newsletters!
Get updates right into your inbox

By providing an email address. I agree to the Terms of Use and acknowledge that I have read the Privacy Policy.
Don't miss out on the latest news and information.
TAGS: bankruptcy, personal finance
For feedback, complaints, or inquiries, contact us.

Subscribe to our newsletters!
Get Updates right into your inbox

By providing an email address. I agree to the Terms of Use and
acknowledge that I have read the Privacy Policy.

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. By continuing, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. To find out more, please click this link.