How much is Mickey Mantle's baseball card worth?

How much is Mickey Mantle’s baseball card worth?

/ 03:42 PM February 24, 2021

The value of Mickey Mantle’s baseball card just shot up into the sky like a homerun. The internet stared in awe as the sports memorabilia sold for a whopping $5.2 million. Meanwhile, you might be wondering how card trading is still a thing nowadays. Well, collectors find a value that goes beyond the edges of those baseball cards.

Mickey Mantle was an excellent baseball player during his time. He set outstanding records in the American League during his 18-year career. Eventually, he became the face of one of the most valuable baseball cards ever. The Mickey Mantle baseball card exchanged several hands until it reached this astounding price.


Surprisingly, people trade baseball cards to earn huge sums potentially. Perhaps you have some in your attic that’s worth millions. If not, read further to learn about one of the best baseball players of yesteryear. More importantly, learn what people see in these memorabilia that they’re willing to shell out a fortune.

Who is Mickey Mantle?

Who is Mickey Mantle?

Photo Credit: Wikipedia

Also nicknamed Mick, Mickey Mantle played for the New York Yankees. He was born on October 20, 1931, in Spavinaw, OK. 

He began playing baseball at Oklahoma’s Commerce High School. Unfortunately, he sustained osteomyelitis after a football injury in 1946.

In 1951, he played his first game for the Yankees as an outfielder. He later replaced Joe DiMaggio in center field. Then in 1967, he went to first base. 

He dealt with a bone disease throughout the majority of his career. Nevertheless, he continued to play baseball while setting exemplary milestones:

  • Played in 2,005 games
  • Named to 20 All-star Games
  • Earned a Gold Glove as a center field
  • 536 home runs
  • Most valuable player of the American League (1956, 1957, and 1962)
  • .421 base average

Sadly, he regretted losing his .300 lifetime batting average. He even lamented this lost record to his friends like Tom Molito, calling it his biggest regret.


On March 1, 1969, Mickey Mantle retired from baseball. He took his place in the National Baseball Hall of Fame in 1974. Finally, he died on August 13, 1995.

How much is Mickey Mantle’s baseball card worth?

How much is Mickey Mantle's baseball card worth?

Photo Credit: Wikipedia

Like most celebrities, his legacy is immortalized in sports memorabilia. Certain people coveted one of those items so much that they were willing to pay $5.2 million.

The card attracting all the online hype was a 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle PSA 9. Actor Rob Gough was the lucky buyer who obtained the Topps card at a staggering price.


Former NFL Super Bowl champ Evan Mathis last sold the rare card in 2018 for $2.88 million. As you can see, the value of collector’s items like this increases as it’s exchanged more times.

Other baseball cards topped the price charts in the past. The previous record was $3.93 million for a signed rookie card of the Los Angeles Angels’ Mike Trout.

On the other hand, similar Mickey Mantle cards pale in comparison to the 1952 variant. Mickey Mantle’s 1951 Bowman Mantle card for only $1.4 million.

However, other high-grade cards dwarf the Mickey Mantle card’s value. Just Collect, and MINT state owner Rick Snyder noted that one of those could sell for $10 million.

Wait, some baseball cards are worth much more?!

Wait, some baseball cards are worth much more?!

Photo Credit: Wikipedia

You might be wondering what the “PSA 9” means. The acronym stands for “Professional Sports Authenticator,” while the number represents the card’s quality.

As you may have guessed, a higher grade indicates better quality. The highest ones have a PSA quality of 10, meaning these are in pristine condition.

There are 3 Mickey Mantle cards with PSA 10 quality, and they’re worth at least $10 million. They’re almost as priceless as art pieces, so the owners aren’t willing to give these cards away.

Surprisingly, one of them stumbled upon the cards in unusual places. Colorado attorney Marshall Fogel found his gem mint baseball card sitting in a truck driver’s attic.

Card trading grew more popular around 2016. Then, ESPN’s release of “The Last Dance” documentary furthered the hype. 

Recently, the pandemic knocked the hype out of the park. More people sought the tinge of nostalgia from these baseball cards.

How Can I Start Trading Cards?

Let’s say you immediately looked for old baseball cards after reading the enormous prices. Now that you’re back with the memorabilia, how can you start selling them?

First, you should check their value. Several factors contribute to the price of Mickey Mantle’s baseball card and similar collector’s items.

Identify the card’s year and the name of the baseball player on it. If the info isn’t indicated, good old Google lets you access online price guides.

Moreover, you might find similar items sold on the internet. These could give your clues on how much you could sell your trading cards.

Then, choose where you could sell your baseball cards. Your options are private online auction houses, card shops & dealers, and eBay.

Why is collecting baseball cards and other stuff popular?

Why is collecting baseball cards and other stuff popular?

Photo Credit: Wikipedia

Card trading may seem strange to some people. For some reason, wealthy individuals find value in seemingly trivial items like postage stamps and sports cards.

As we’ve mentioned, some people buy these items for nostalgia. They may have idolized athletes like Mickey Mantle in their youth, and trading cards preserve that treasured moment.

Moreover, these relics could provide insights into historical figures and periods. For instance, antique paintings captured iconic moments before the age of photographs.

Some collectibles could teach scientific insights and current events. For example, sedimentary rocks have several layers of the Earth’s surface throughout thousands of years.

People have their reasons why they collect stuff. Some might be willing to shell out $5.2 million for a baseball legend’s memorabilia.

Final Thoughts

One of the Mickey Mantle baseball cards sold for millions of dollars. As we’ve said, others could be worth much more by now.

Yet, their owners are unwilling to let their cards go for any price. Some view them as priceless artworks, while others see beyond their monetary value.

People determine the value of everything around them. Others may dismiss trading cards as old pieces of cardboard. For some sports fans, these are priceless relics of baseball history.

Subscribe to our newsletters! Get updates right into your inbox

By providing an email address. I agree to the Terms of Use and acknowledge that I have read the Privacy Policy.
Don't miss out on the latest news and information.
TAGS: baseball, sports
For feedback, complaints, or inquiries, contact us.

Subscribe to our newsletters!
Get Updates right into your inbox

By providing an email address. I agree to the Terms of Use and
acknowledge that I have read the Privacy Policy.

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. By continuing, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. To find out more, please click this link.