Advertorial or Sponsorship User published Content does not represent the views of the Company or any individual associated with the Company, and we do not control this Content. In no event shall you represent or suggest, directly or indirectly, the Company's endorsement of user published Content.
The company does not vouch for the accuracy or credibility of any user published Content on our Website and does not take any responsibility or assume any liability for any actions you may take as a result of reading user published Content on our Website.
Through your use of the Website and Services, you may be exposed to Content that you may find offensive, objectionable, harmful, inaccurate, or deceptive.
By using our Website, you assume all associated risks.This Website contains hyperlinks to other websites controlled by third parties. These links are provided solely as a convenience to you and do not imply endorsement by the Company of, or any affiliation with, or endorsement by, the owner of the linked website.
Company is not responsible for the contents or use of any linked website, or any consequence of making the link.
Gemma & Karimi Reviews and Ratings

Gemma & Karimi, LLP provides specialized criminal defense representation in Indianapolis.
Gemma & Karimi is an Indianapolis criminal defense firm. Two partners run it. Ron Gemma leads one side. Kevin Karimi is a former Marion County prosecutor. Both have won Super Lawyers Rising Star honors. Kevin Karimi also holds a perfect 10.0 Avvo rating. A criminal charge in Indianapolis is scary. The choice of lawyer feels huge, and the clock is ticking. The local market makes it harder. Many firms look the same. They promise the same wins and hide their fees. This review shows what Gemma & Karimi does well and where it falls short. We use public records and outside ratings, not ads.
What is Gemma & Karimi?
Gemma & Karimi is a criminal defense firm in downtown Indianapolis. The office is at 320 N. Meridian Street, Suite 916. You can call the team at (317) 602-5970. Ron Gemma started the firm around 2013. He has always defended the accused. Kevin Karimi spent about five years as a Marion County prosecutor. Then he switched sides and joined as a partner in 2017.
The firm says it handles criminal cases only. That narrow focus is the heart of its pitch. It also uses the name indianadefenseteam.com. So you may see both names online.
What criminal defense representation covers
A criminal defense firm stands between you and the state. Its job is to protect your rights. That work starts at the first police contact. It can run through trial or appeal. It is not the same as family law, injury law, or business law. Do not mix up these types.
Most cases move through clear stages. First comes the arrest and an initial hearing. Then come charges, discovery, and pretrial motions. Your lawyer reviews the proof.
They file motions to toss out weak evidence. They also talk terms with the prosecutor. A lot of that proof is now digital. A good team knows how to test digital evidence before a jury sees it. If no deal works, the case goes to trial. After a verdict, there may be sentencing or an appeal.
A defense lawyer guides each step. They explain your choices in plain words. That helps you decide with a clear head.
Services
Gemma & Karimi lists many criminal defense tracks on its site. Here are the main ones.
DUI and OWI defense
The firm handles drunk and drugged driving cases. These range from a first misdemeanor to a felony. A DUI can cost you your license, your job, and your record. The team checks the stop, the testing, and the arrest for weak spots.
Drug crimes
Gemma & Karimi defends possession, dealing, and trafficking charges. The firm says it fights claims that you meant to sell. It also looks for search and seizure problems. Each case turns on the facts and the proof.
Violent crimes
The firm takes on battery, assault, robbery, and homicide cases. These charges carry the highest stakes. So trial readiness matters. The team preps each case as if it will reach a jury.
Sex crimes
Gemma & Karimi handle charges like sexual assault and child-related offenses. These cases are sensitive. They carry lasting harm. The firm stresses a careful, private defense.
Expungement
The firm helps clients clear or seal old records when the law allows. A clean record can open doors for jobs and housing. What you qualify for depends on the charge and the outcome.
Weapons and white-collar charges
The team also defends gun charges, internet crimes, and white collar cases. These matters often turn on documents and digital records. The firm checks how the state gathered its proof.
Gemma & Karimi at a glance

Gemma & Karimi, LLP is a top-rated criminal defense law firm serving the Indianapolis area.
Here are the key facts in one place. Gemma & Karimi sits at 320 N. Meridian Street, Suite 916, Indianapolis, IN 46204. You can reach the team at (317) 602-5970. Ron Gemma and Kevin Karimi run the firm, and they handle criminal defense only. The firm reports about 25 years of combined experience. Both partners have won Super Lawyers Rising Star honors across several years. It offers a free first meeting, by its own account. The office is open Monday to Friday, from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Cost
Gemma & Karimi does not post its fees online. That is common for criminal defense firms. Price depends on the charge and the work. Still, it is a transparency gap when you compare firms. The firm does offer a free first meeting. You can ask about price before you commit. One Yelp reviewer said the firm charged extra for calls and texts past a few minutes on its app. We could not confirm this. Treat it as one account. Ask about billing rules up front. Get the fee terms in writing before you sign.
The former-prosecutor advantage
Kevin Karimi was a Marion County prosecutor from 2012 to 2017. He handled major felonies, DUI cases, and misdemeanors. Then he moved to defense. That background matters.
A former prosecutor knows how the state builds a case. He also knows where it tends to slip. That insight can lead to stronger motions and smarter plea talks. This is an edge, not a promise. No lawyer can promise a result. Past work does not fix a future case.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Kevin Karimi holds a 10.0 Superb Avvo rating. It is the top score the site gives. The mark reflects his experience, peer support, and clean record.
- Both partners have won Super Lawyers Rising Star honors for several years. Peers pick these lists, so they carry weight.
- The firm does criminal defense only. The team is in these courts every day.
- The team has a former Marion County prosecutor. Few small firms offer that inside view.
- Gemma & Karimi gives a free first meeting. You can test the fit before you pay.
- Ratings are strong where they exist. Yelp shows a 5.0. Martindale shows a 4.6 from 32 reviews. Both point to happy clients.
Cons
- The firm does not post fees online. You cannot compare price without a call.
- Review counts are thin on some sites. Facebook has only 3 reviews and no rating. Yelp has just 6.
- One Yelp reviewer flagged surprise billing for calls and texts. We could not confirm it. Still, it is worth asking about.
- The firm is small. Two partners carry the load. A big firm may answer faster after hours.
- One reviewer questioned whether the Google reviews are genuine. We could not verify that claim either way.
- We could not find a BBB profile for the firm. So its BBB grade stays unconfirmed.
Who Gemma & Karimi is best for
- People with DUI or OWI charges in Marion County who want a focused team.
- People who value a former prosecutor’s read on how the state works.
- People who want a small firm where a named partner handles the case.
- People who want to ask the right questions before hiring and get straight answers in a free meeting.
Who should avoid Gemma & Karimi
- People who need a non-criminal case, like divorce, injury, or business law.
- People outside Indiana, or with a case in another state’s courts.
- People who need posted flat-fee pricing before a first call.
- People who want a big firm with many lawyers and staffed lines all day.
Gemma & Karimi reviews and ratings, what clients report

Client feedback highlights the personalized and attentive legal support provided by Gemma & Karimi.
Here is what the main review sites showed in July 2026. Numbers change. Confirm each one before you decide.
Google Reviews
Gemma & Karimi scores well on Google. Review trackers that sync its Google Business Profile show a 4.9 star rating from about 129 Google reviews as of July 2026. That is a strong score backed by real volume. One Yelp reviewer did question how the firm gathered its Google reviews. We could not verify that claim. So confirm the live count yourself before you decide.
Avvo
Avvo scores both partners well. Kevin Karimi holds a 10.0 rating, marked Superb. He has 31 client reviews and an Avvo Client Choice badge. Ron Gemma holds an 8.2 rating, marked Excellent. His reviews average 5.0. These figures were current in July 2026.
Martindale-Hubbell
On Martindale-Hubbell and Lawyers.com, Kevin Karimi shows a 4.6 rating from 32 reviews. He also holds an Avvo Client Choice honor. The profile lists client and peer feedback. It spans criminal defense, drug crimes, and homicide defense. These numbers were current in July 2026.
Yelp
Yelp lists Gemma & Karimi at 5.0 stars from 6 reviews in July 2026. The count is low. So weigh each review with care. One recent one-star review called the firm’s Google ratings misleading. It also claimed extra charges for long calls and texts. Read the full thread and judge for yourself.
Reddit threads on Indianapolis criminal defense do not name Gemma & Karimi as of July 2026. Locals in r/indianapolis point to other firms and public defenders. That gap is not a knock on the firm. But it means there is no community review to cite yet. Open the linked thread to see how locals pick a defense lawyer.
State bar and BBB
Both attorneys look to be in good standing with the Indiana bar. We found no public discipline record. Confirm this yourself through the Indiana Roll of Attorneys. We could not find a BBB profile for the firm. So treat its BBB status as unconfirmed. Check both before you hire.
Gemma & Karimi vs. Keffer Hirschauer LLP
Keffer Hirschauer LLP makes a good comparison. It is another Indianapolis criminal defense and OWI firm. Former deputy prosecutors built it. Both firms share a former-prosecutor edge. Both focus on criminal work.
The two differ in size and reach. Keffer Hirschauer runs a larger team. It also holds more public Google reviews. Gemma & Karimi is a smaller shop. A named partner handles your file there. Neither firm posts flat fees online.
Check the current figures for both firms before you choose. Ratings and staff change. These notes reflect public info in July 2026.
Is Gemma & Karimi legit?
Yes. The firm is a real, licensed Indianapolis practice. Both partners hold active Indiana law licenses. We found no public discipline record. The firm has run for more than ten years. It keeps a downtown office at 320 N. Meridian Street. Outside signals back this up. Kevin Karimi has a 10.0 Avvo rating. The firm also holds a 4.9 Google rating from about 129 reviews. Both partners hold Super Lawyers Rising Star honors. Some claims are firm-reported, like case results and combined experience. Weigh those as such.
Gemma & Karimi review verdict
A charge in Indianapolis is scary. The wrong lawyer can cost you more than money. The hard part is telling strong firms from loud ones. Every site makes the same promises. Gemma & Karimi earns a careful yes for the right client. It offers a focused defense practice. It brings a former prosecutor’s insight. It also has solid outside marks. Those include a 4.9 Google rating from about 129 reviews. They also include a 5.0 Yelp rating from 6 reviews. And they include a 10.0 Avvo score for Kevin Karimi in July 2026. Just ask about fees in writing. And confirm the current ratings before you sign.
Legal disclaimer
This article is for information only. It is not legal advice. Past results do not promise future outcomes. Media mentions are ads, not proof of approval. Ratings and counts reflect public sources in July 2026. They may change. Confirm all details with the firm and state records before you act.